Choosing the right concealed carry pistol is a deeply personal decision, heavily influenced by individual hand size, shooting style, and intended use. Two popular contenders frequently top the list: the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus and the Springfield Armory Hellcat. This in-depth comparison will explore their key features, helping you determine which firearm best fits your needs.
Key Differences and Similarities: A Quick Overview
Both the M&P Shield Plus and the Hellcat are striker-fired, single-stack 9mm pistols designed for concealed carry. They share a focus on compact size and high capacity for their class. However, crucial differences exist in grip size, capacity, trigger, and overall feel.
| Feature | M&P Shield Plus | Hellcat |
|---|---|---|
| Caliber | 9mm | 9mm |
| Capacity | 10+1 (13+1 with extended magazine) | 11+1 (13+1 with extended magazine) |
| Grip Size | Slightly larger, more substantial grip | Significantly smaller, more compact grip |
| Trigger | Generally smoother, crisper, more predictable | Can feel slightly gritty or mushy (varies) |
| Overall Size | Slightly larger footprint | Significantly smaller footprint |
| Weight | Slightly heavier | Slightly lighter |
| Price | Similar pricing range | Similar pricing range |
Detailed Comparison: M&P Shield Plus
The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus builds upon the success of its predecessor, offering improvements in several key areas.
Advantages of the M&P Shield Plus:
- Ergonomics: The Shield Plus boasts a noticeably larger and more substantial grip, making it easier for shooters with larger hands to achieve a comfortable and controlled grip. This translates to improved accuracy and reduced recoil.
- Improved Trigger: Many users find the Shield Plus trigger smoother and more predictable than the Hellcat's, contributing to a more consistent shooting experience.
- Slightly Larger Capacity (Standard Magazine): While the difference is minimal, the Shield Plus offers a standard magazine capacity of 10+1, compared to the Hellcat's 11+1 (though both offer 13+1 extended magazines).
Disadvantages of the M&P Shield Plus:
- Size and Concealability: Its slightly larger size and weight compared to the Hellcat might make it less ideal for deep concealment for individuals with smaller frames.
Detailed Comparison: Hellcat
The Springfield Armory Hellcat quickly gained popularity due to its remarkably compact size and surprisingly high capacity for such a small pistol.
Advantages of the Hellcat:
- Concealability: The Hellcat's diminutive size makes it exceptionally easy to conceal, even for individuals with smaller builds. This is its primary advantage.
- High Capacity for its Size: Its 11+1 round capacity (13+1 with extended magazine) is impressive, maximizing firepower in a compact package.
Disadvantages of the Hellcat:
- Grip Size and Ergonomics: The significantly smaller grip can be challenging for shooters with larger hands, potentially leading to discomfort and reduced accuracy.
- Trigger Feel: Some users report a less-than-ideal trigger feel, describing it as gritty or mushy. This is subjective and can vary from firearm to firearm.
Conclusion: Which is Right for You?
The "better" pistol depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences.
-
Choose the M&P Shield Plus if: You prioritize a comfortable grip, smoother trigger, and slightly larger capacity, and concealability isn't your paramount concern. Larger hands will generally find the Shield Plus easier to shoot accurately.
-
Choose the Hellcat if: Concealability is your top priority, and you're comfortable with a smaller grip, even if it means potentially compromising on ergonomics and trigger feel. The Hellcat excels in disappearing beneath clothing.
Ultimately, the best approach is to handle both pistols (if possible) and test fire them (at a range) to determine which feels more natural and comfortable in your hand. Consider factors like your hand size, shooting experience, and clothing choices when making your decision. Remember to always prioritize safe gun handling practices.
